FBA Custom Login But No Windows Authentication

Question

Hi,

I have Claim based web application.Configured FBA successfully.Created custom login page which is working fine.But I observed one problem:Only FBA users can login.The default login have a dropdown for both windows and FBA.I think the best approach would be create another login page for Windows Users.But is this possible without Extending the web application.Just another login page for Windows Users.Is this possible?

---

I am too late but i will never give up

Answer 1

Hi,

If you have a Claim based web application , you only have to enable Win Auth and FBA Auth from Authentication providers and then create one custom login page for both.

Check this example

http://tomaszrabinski.pl/wordpress/2011/06/23/sharepoint-2010-custom-login-page/

---

Regards,
Fadi Abdulwahab, SharePoint Consultant
http://blogs.msdn.com/b/fabdulwahab
http://sqlgoogler.blogspot.com/

Answer 2

Hi,

If you have a Claim based web application , you only have to enable Win Auth and FBA Auth from Authentication providers and then create one custom login page for both.

Check this example

http://tomaszrabinski.pl/wordpress/2011/06/23/sharepoint-2010-custom-login-page/

---

Regards,
Fadi Abdulwahab, SharePoint Consultant
http://blogs.msdn.com/b/fabdulwahab
http://sqlgoogler.blogspot.com/

That is great but what if we want it separated :One for FBA and other for Windows Login.Is this possible?

---

I am too late but i will never give up

Answer 3

>That is great but what if we want it separated :One for FBA and other for Windows Login.Is this possible?

---

Yes this is possible. You need to extend your web application in another port so you can use one for FBA and another one for windows.

Check this MSDN article for more information about this:

http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/cc261698.aspx

Hope it could help

---

Cheers, Hemendra-MCTS "Yesterday is just a memory,Tomorrow we may never see"

Answer 4

>That is great but what if we want it separated :One for FBA and other for Windows Login.Is this possible?

---

Yes this is possible. You need to extend your web application in another port so you can use one for FBA and another one for windows.

Check this MSDN article for more information about this:

http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/cc261698.aspx

Hope it could help

---

Cheers, Hemendra-MCTS "Yesterday is just a memory,Tomorrow we may never see"

Thank you for your reply.I mentioned this in my first post:"But is this possible without Extending the web application".Your reply means it is not possible without extending.If I didn't have a different reply I will mark Fadi reply as answer and use it and mark yours as helpful...

---

I am too late but i will never give up

Answer 5

Hi,

>I mentioned this in my first post

Sorry about this i have missed that point. As Fadi said you can create custom login page to authenticate both users. You can mark his reply as answer.

---

Cheers, Hemendra-MCTS "Yesterday is just a memory,Tomorrow we may never see"

Answer 6

Hi,

>I mentioned this in my first post

Sorry about this i have missed that point. As Fadi said you can create custom login page to authenticate both users. You can mark his reply as answer.

---

Cheers, Hemendra-MCTS "Yesterday is just a memory,Tomorrow we may never see"

No Problem but your reply means it is impossible to have two login pages without extend.

But I just thought about this now:I think it is more secured.I will test the first idea on my development laptop.But after that I will test using extend to add FBA to a windows classic web application.If I face any problem I will start a new question thread.Thanks alot...    

---

I am too late but i will never give up